作业帮 > 英语 > 作业

这个句子错误在哪I gave the book to him that he needed it.我觉得错误应该是从句跟

来源:学生作业帮 编辑:搜搜做题作业网作业帮 分类:英语作业 时间:2024/05/02 18:14:28
这个句子错误在哪
I gave the book to him that he needed it.
我觉得错误应该是从句跟错了先行词,然后还多了个it 因为that已经代替it做needed的宾语了.我改的是如下:
I gave the book that he needed to him.
但是我看答案的该法是:I gave the book to him that he needed(仅仅是去掉了it).还是我一开始理解错了?定语从句不是应该紧跟先行词么.这里先行词应该是book把?
这个句子错误在哪I gave the book to him that he needed it.我觉得错误应该是从句跟
定语从句后面很少再接东西的 介词短语放在give的后面
i gave the book to him
然后是什么书呢? the book he need
i gave the book to him which he needed.
再问: 对啊,什么书呢?那个定语从句也肯定是修饰书的。可是不是说定语从句必须要跟在他修饰的先行词后面么。
你前面说定语从句后面不接东西,可是定语从句后面借东西我见很多都这样啊比如:The people who live next to me are my friend。我理解是:定语从句就是他修饰的那个名词的一部分,他后面接不接东西,跟定语从句没关系。我理解的有问题么?还请指导。
再答: 我感觉你理解的没错
跟例子里的那句一样 the people are my friend
那些人是the people who lice next to me
i gave the book (that he needed) to him 这样也是对的
再问: 后面又出现了一道题是这样的:
The woman was nice that i met yesterday.
答案强调该句子有错的改法就是:
The woman that i met yesterday was nice.
你看这里他特意强调要把定语从句从句末拉到先行词后面。但是上一题他却把定语从句放到句末。。目前只能理解为to him不算句子成分,可以摆放随意位置。。